A Godwink Christmas (2018) on Netflix

Plot summary

Paula Mayer works as an antique appraiser at Bishop's Auction Co. in St. Louis, where she quietly dreams of running her own antiques shop. As the holiday approaches she agrees to marry Daniel O'Brian, an attorney, though the engagement leaves her uneasy and she cannot say why. Her aunt Jane, a writer, invites her to Nantucket for the weekend to sort it out, but Jane's work intervenes and Paula heads alone to Martha's Vineyard for the day. There she keeps crossing paths with Gery Conover, who owns the Charlotte Inn and volunteers at the island's youth center. When the weather strands her, she stays on and joins the island's Christmas festivities with him. Gery has a past heartache that first brought him to Martha's Vineyard, and both of them weigh how far the connection can go.