Love Finds You In Sugarcreek (2014) on Netflix

Plot summary

Rachel Troyler is a policewoman in Sugarcreek, Ohio, an Amish town where her three aunts live. Bertha, Anna and Lydia raised Rachel after she was orphaned, and they keep the Sugar Haus Inn, a farmhouse that has seen better days. Joe and his five-year-old son, Bobby, appear at the door, and the aunts, following their faith, offer the two a place to stay. Joe helps around the inn as a handyman, and a child is in the house again. Rachel's instincts tell her that this penniless stranger is too polished for the drifter he says he is. Wary of him and drawn to him at once, she sets out to find out who he truly is.