The Good Witch's Garden (2009) on Netflix

Plot summary

Middleton is getting ready for its bicentennial, and Grey House will host the celebration. Cassie Nightingale is turning the house into a bed and breakfast when her first guest, Nick Chasen, arrives with documents that name him the only heir of captain Hamblin, the colonial era builder. Nick says the Grey Lady, the captain's companion, kept the property after he disappeared, and the city council comes to trust him. Jake Russell, the chief of police and Cassie's boyfriend, pushes her to contest the claim rather than hand the house over. Meanwhile, Jake's son Brandon Russell is dared by two local boys, Steve and Duke, to pass an initiation, and George O'Hanrahan's gardening brings him a romance.